Are Sore Muscles After A Workout Such A Good Thing? You Might Not Want To Hear This Answer.

You may have seen one of those fitness motivation posters that's been making the rounds claims “I don't stop when I'm tired. I stop when I'm done.” Maybe it's time to stop and do a reality check.

This might piss off some of the fitness addicts that will push through anything and thrive on muscle soreness. But I'd rather serve it to you straight and hopefully help you avoid injury in the future.

The problem with this kind of thinking is that you can do more damage to your muscles if you don't stop and give them a chance to recover. Working out causes microscopic tears in muscle fibers and surrounding tissue which then inflame, causing the soreness (the lactic acid explanation is a myth, btw). Overworking them causes more tears and more inflammation, increasing the recovery time.

We agree with Josh Feldman here and suggest you avoid overdoing it. Don't be afraid to stop – you're not giving up here. You're giving your body a chance to recover properly so you can get back to working out sooner.

Pay attention to what your body is telling you and don't ignore it.  Develop and tune your mind-body connection because it can only help you avoid getting hurt as you get fit.


Does Muscle Soreness Mean You Had a Good Workout?

We're looking at you, Ms. I-can't-move-my-arms-today


The question: I went to the gym yesterday and now I have sore muscles. That means I had a great workout, right?

The expert: Josh Feldman, a certified personal trainer and fitness manager at Crunch Fitness in New York City

The answer: Not really. While working your muscles until they’re achy means you technically did tax your muscles, which helps them get stronger, it’s actually not beneficial work in the long run.

The reason? Pushing it to the max one day means you’re going to be too sore to hit the gym the next day, or the day after that. And that’s a serious issue, because consistency is the ultimate goal here. “It’s way more important to be able to exercise every day or every other day than to just kill it one day and not be able to move for four or five days after that,” explains Feldman.

In other words, it all comes down to the basic fact that moving more often is better for you than going all gung-ho for a bit, and then proceeding to kick it on the couch while muttering all sorts of FML, dear-muscles-I-hate-you lines. “You can't just say, ‘I went hard a few days ago so I've done my time for the week,' because your muscles don't operate like that. They respond better when they’re being constantly worked—that prevents them from becoming weak and inactive,” Feldman continues.

So how can you tell when you’re about to overdo it? Well, if you start shaking or twitching during your reps, that’s a sure sign that you’re going to feel it big time tomorrow—so do yourself a favor and step awaaay from the weights. But even something as simple as feeling more tired halfway through your second set than you did at the end of the first means it’s time to stop, too.

Your sore-muscle Rx, then, is this: As soon as you start feeling noticeably exhausted, end the session. “That way, you’ll be able to come back the next day or the day after and therefore keep the muscles moving more consistently overall,” concludes Feldman.

SOURCE: Annie Daly on

IMAGES: HEADER (cropped) by istolethetv on Flickr

Author: Peter Tiedemann

Share This Post On


  1. DOMS Got You Down? Use This Remarkably Simple Method To Ease The Pain And Improve Recovery. - Get Fit, Not Injured - […] another article we did mention that it’s better to stop before you get to the point of damaging your…

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *